Are medical alert systems with GPS for elderly with dementia worth the investment, wearable vs. mobile apps?

Question

Tyler Smith · Accepted Answer

For elderly individuals living with dementia, particularly those prone to wandering or who spend time alone, medical alert systems with GPS tracking can be a life-changing investment. The question of whether they are 'worth it' often boils down to peace of mind for both the senior and their caregivers, balanced against cost and specific features. Buyers frequently ask about the reliability and ease of use for different formats.

Wearable Medical Alert Systems with GPS

These typically come as pendants, bracelets, or watches. They are designed for easy, constant wear and often include features beyond just location tracking.

Pros:

• Always On Hand: Worn on the body, they are less likely to be forgotten or left behind. This is crucial for individuals with memory impairment.
• Emergency Call Button: Most models include a prominent button that connects to a 24/7 monitoring center or pre-programmed contacts, enabling quick response in an emergency, such as a fall or disorientation.
• Automatic Fall Detection: Many advanced wearables offer this feature, which can be invaluable for seniors with balance issues. Based on verified purchases, this function is highly valued by caregivers.
• Geofencing: Caregivers can set safe zones, receiving alerts if the wearer leaves a designated area, like their home or neighborhood.
• Two-Way Communication: Allows the senior to speak directly through the device to emergency services or family, enhancing feelings of security.
• Discreet Design: Modern options are often sleek, resembling regular watches, which can reduce stigma.

Cons:

• Battery Life: Requires regular charging, which can be a challenge for someone with dementia.
• Monthly Fees: Most comprehensive services involve a subscription for monitoring and GPS features.
• Potential for Discomfort or Removal: Some seniors with dementia might forget to wear the device or intentionally remove it if it feels unfamiliar.

Mobile Apps for GPS Tracking

These are applications installed on a smartphone or tablet that can track the device's location. Some apps are designed specifically for elder care, while others are general family trackers.

Pros:

• Cost-Effective: Often a lower initial cost, sometimes free for basic tracking, utilizing an existing smartphone.
• Familiar Device: If the senior is already comfortable using a smartphone, it can be an easier transition.
• Additional Smartphone Features: Provides access to other phone functionalities, like calling or messaging, which can be beneficial if the senior retains some cognitive function.

Cons:

• Easily Forgotten or Lost: A senior with dementia may misplace their phone, forget to carry it, or simply not keep it charged.
• Dependence on Phone Use: Requires the senior to actively carry and maintain their phone, which is often unreliable for those with significant memory issues.
• No Dedicated Emergency Button: While some apps offer an SOS feature, it is generally less immediate and reliable than a dedicated button on a wearable device.
• Privacy Concerns: General tracking apps might raise privacy issues if not specifically designed for elder care with clear consent.
• Lack of Monitoring Center: Most apps rely on family members to monitor, without the 24/7 professional response of a medical alert service.

Is it Worth the Investment?

For elderly individuals with dementia, especially those with a risk of wandering, wearable medical alert systems with GPS are generally a more robust and reliable investment. They are specifically designed for emergencies and ease of use in challenging situations. Based on consumer feedback, the peace of mind provided by 24/7 professional monitoring and automatic fall detection far outweighs the monthly fee for many families. While mobile apps can supplement, they typically lack the dedicated safety features and reliability needed for serious dementia care.

Before making a decision, consider the senior's cognitive state, their willingness to wear a device, their tech-savviness, and the specific level of monitoring and support needed. A trial period, if available, can also help assess suitability.